Jason and Travis Kelce Divulge Their Favorite Girl Scout Cookies

The Kelce brothers gave fans another treat by opening up about yet another food choice.

Jason and Travis Kelce are no strangers to snacking, and based on their previous admissions regarding a few other of their preferred foods, we bet you can guess their favorite flavor of Girl Scout Cookie (hint: their favorite cereal is Reese’s Puffs).

During the latest episode of the NFL star brothers’ sports podcast, New Heights, which was released on Wednesday, Jan. 17, Travis and Jason answered inquiries from fans as part of their weekly “No Dumb Questions” segment of the audio show.

One question called for them to “settle the debate” for a troupe of Girl Scouts, who wanted to know what the pro athletes’ favorite Girl Scout Cookie is—and if you’ve been tuning in, it’s not very surprising.

The Philadelphia Eagles center, who just opened up about his plans to retire earlier this week, took the opportunity to take the lead in answering: “Just like our favorite cereal and candy, it’s something with peanut butter and chocolate,” he noted before Travis joined in as they said together, “Tagalongs!”

“Can’t beat it,” the Catching Kelce alum insisted.

For those unfamiliar, Tagalongs are “crispy cookies layered with peanut butter and covered with a chocolaty coating,” according to the snack’s description on the organization’s official website, so it seems like simply put, these two just have a thing for chocolate/peanut butter-flavored items.

Travis, did, however, follow up on the choice, by admitting that he also does “enjoy” the “lemon cookie,” as it is a “nice switch-up.” Since it seems he couldn’t land on their exact name, the jury is still out on which lemon-flavored cookie he was referring to, as Girl Scouts offers both Lemonades—savory, refreshing shortbread cookies topped with a tangy lemon-flavored icing—and Lemon-Ups—crispy lemon cookies baked with inspiring messages—as showcased on the variety roundup online.